In 2017, Robinson Fruchtl received the NCAA Silver Anniversary Award, which is given annually to recognize distinguished individuals on the 25th anniversary of the conclusion of their collegiate athletic careers.
During Robinson Fruchtl's leadership, Saint Francis Athletics won its first Brenda Weare Commissioner's Cup and 10 Northeast Conference Championship titles, as well as claiming the Joan Martin Cup in 2017-18. SFU also won the NEC Building Communities Award two years in a row (2017-18, 2018-19) and earned its first NIT appearance for men's basketball (2019) since 1958.
In addition, the Red Flash student-athletes continued to excel in the classroom under Robinson Fruchtl's watch, obtaining the highest semester GPA in the department's history with a 3.409 in the spring of 2018. She helped continue the great academic success with 41 consecutive semesters with a grade-point average of 3.0 or higher.
The university also undertook facility improvements during her time as Director of Athletics including: renovating DeGol Arena and the Men's & Women's Golf Indoor Training Center, creating a Short Game Area at Immergrun Golf Course, upgrading the women's soccer and women's volleyball locker rooms, and adding a new public restroom facility at DeGol Field.
Among Robinson Fruchtl's other accomplishments during her time in Loretto are leading the initiative to achieve the football equivalency which will allow SFU to play FBS opponents starting the fall of 2020 and bringing numerous District 6 and PIAA competitions to Saint Francis' campus.